Submitted by Alaa on Sat, 05/06/2004 - 00:59.

My suggestion for the AUP is to adopt what NewComer proposed and to revisit the AUP again as soon as we get a sizable number of members.

The current poll shows the community is divided by half on allowing profanity, but almost all agree on no personal attacks and hate speech, at the moment we shall adopt the more conservative choice (since it got a majority of sorts) but obviously the topic needs to be reconsidered again.


The Acceptable Use Policy

Purpose

The Acceptable Use Policy is a simple set of guidelines determining behavior in eglug. The intention is not to restrict, but rather to provide the barest possible protection for members in order to provide a respectable and constructive working environment for the site. The AUP is as follows.

The Policy

The following kinds of speech will not be allowed on the eglug.org website:

  1. No content violating the laws of Egypt.
  2. No Hate speech against individuals or groups.
  3. No personal attacks.
  4. No Profanity or sexualy explicit content.
  5. No off topic content.

Topic

This LUG was founded to promote the ideals of Free/Open Source Software and GNU/Linux. Members are expected to keep the topic of work and discussion in this area as much as they can. It is understood that the line between on-topic and off-topic is sometimes not too clear, and the benefit of the doubt will be given as often as possible. Only clear violations of this rule will be considered a violation of the Acceptable Use Policy.

Blogs

Blogs are a special area of the eglug.org website, their goal is to foster community and to enable social interaction between members.

The rule about off topic content is relaxed fully when it comes to blogs, blog writers can write about anything they want as long as they don't violate the rest of the rules.

When it comes to religion and philosophy, you have the right to express your believes even if it contradicts other religions as long as it doesn't insult/attack them, there's a very fine line between both.

Moderation

It is moderators duty to ensure that content published on the eglug.org website does not violate the rules stated above.

Moderators are to avoid editing members posts, they should instead unpublish the post and ask the author to edit the post till it complies with the rules.

Moderators shall not delete content from the website permenantly, posts violating the rules shall be unpublished and moved to a locked location, any member has the right to request monitoring moderation descisions and looking at moderated posts.

A public trail of the moderation descision citing the author of the violating post, the name of the moderator and the reason for moderation shall be provided, failure to do so will be considered violation of the moderators mandate.

Any moderation descision can be revoked through the consensus of 3 moderators.


I did not actualy give this much thought, and I'd like to hear feedback about it.


Manal's picture
Submitted by Manal on Mon, 07/06/2004 - 11:14.

I agree on everything, and I like the bit about unpublishing the moderated post instead of deleting because every one has the right to know what happened and monitor the whole process.


http://www.manalaa.net


whirlpool's picture
Submitted by whirlpool on Tue, 08/06/2004 - 22:15.

The AUP should include something avatars that include images or symbols that are illegal, carry hate messages. Any of the top 4 rules.

An example would be matata's avatar that depicts a tux with inverted cross on its chest.


Alaa's picture
Submitted by Alaa on Tue, 08/06/2004 - 23:34.

AUP covers the whole site, avatars and signatures are personal areas as such they get the same rules as blogs.

maybe we should change the language to mention personal areas, and then define personal areas as blogs, avatars, signatures, etc.

but a joke is a joke we should not loose our sense of humor over stupid details (there is nothing in egpytian law against satanism anyway, even al neyaba said so back in the dark era of youth musician prosecution).

cheers, Alaa


http://www.manalaa.net


YoussefAssad's picture
Submitted by YoussefAssad on Mon, 14/06/2004 - 09:36.
  • Blogs. Okay. But mention that religious material will be VERY CLOSELY MONITORED by the mods. This one worries me.

-- Linux Egypt Lice Resident


whirlpool's picture
Submitted by whirlpool on Sat, 19/06/2004 - 15:47.

Since the blogs have a collective RSS feed. I think that we should publish such feeds on RSS search engines like Feedster. This way the offensive content will be wide open to the whole internet public. Anyone who thinks there is something offensive may reply anonymously and the admins will notice if there is a problem and take the apropriate actions.

Also web site statistics and refererals can highlight anything contorversial and spreading popularly on the net pretty quickly.


MohammedSameer's picture
Submitted by MohammedSameer on Wed, 16/06/2004 - 12:37.

> blog writers can write about anything they want as > long as they don't violate the rest of the rules. so I can violate only 1 rule per blog entry, Or what ?

> When it comes to religion and philosophy, you have the right to > express your believes even if it contradicts other religions as > long as it doesn't insult/attack them. how ? examples needed here.

> any member has the right to request monitoring moderation descisions and looking at moderated posts. HIS moderated posts, And we should attach/add/...... a few lines to the moderated post to explain why it was moderated, so ppl don't forget the reason.

> Any moderation descision can be revoked through the consensus of 3 moderators. 1 addmin vote = 1 moderator vote. right ?

-- I was known as Uniball!
Katoob Main developer
PekSysTray - GtkFlame


Submitted by NewComer on Mon, 05/07/2004 - 21:55.

I think that the rules applying on blogs should be applied on the IRC channel, one can find a lot of indecent speach in the channel, the place where people should come for help.

YoussefAssad's picture
Submitted by YoussefAssad on Tue, 06/07/2004 - 10:32.

Makes sense.

-- Linux Egypt Lice Resident


Alaa's picture
Submitted by Alaa on Tue, 06/07/2004 - 12:08.

what makes an AUP important for the website is its permenant nature, IRC chats are not permenant and I see no reason to restrict it.

cheers,
Alaa


http://www.manalaa.net

"u know i once dream that the office of mobinil is from el 7`os :S and the one that answer u and tell u rasidak a girl called ghada"


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.