Submitted by OneOfOne on Mon, 07/06/2004 - 20:37.
( categories: Miscellaneous )

Well, I've been using reiser4 for over 3 months now and using it as my / partition for about a month.

here're some interesting findings.

1. It IS faster than every file system out there, including reiserfs v3.6, no benchmarks but the system starts faster, games load faster, copying files is faster, etc.

2. It handles power going out/computer freezes pretty well (better than reiserfs/ext*).

3. old snapshot in speedy-sources worked fine but mysql database went corrupt randomly under heavy usage and bittorrent/amule had corrupt downloads.

4. new snapshot in love-sources-2.6.7_rc2-r2 locks the computer "after" heavy load (keyword after, not during), for example I can play ut2004 fine but 5 minutes after I finish playing it locks up the computer, although I can usually sync, umount and reboot cleanly with alt+sysrq.

5. I can play enemy-territory just fine, and I can emerge (compile) most stuff just fine, but for example the system locks up "after" emerging php/coreutils.

Other known bugs:

1. glibc/apache have permission problems because of the metas/ feature of reiser4, I've made a fix for that to disable metas/ by default and I'm testing it before i release it to the public.

2. apache randomly goes zombie and makes the "system" use 99% CPU (not apache itself).

Overall reiser4 is definitely a good test-filesystem, but it still needs to be more mature.

I recommend everyone to try it, It is NOT the most stable filesystem out there, but hey I can show you ext2, ext3, reiserfs, xfs horror stories so nothing is stable enough.

peace


Alaa's picture
Submitted by Alaa on Mon, 07/06/2004 - 21:09.

yeah except ext2, ext3 horror stories happened for corner cases.

anyways, what about JFS recent benchmarks showed it performed very well (even better than reiser at times) and overall its CPU usage (my main beef with reiser) was lower and it fared well with large files.

also JFS has a good stability record.

tried it at all?

cheers, Alaa


http://www.manalaa.net


OneOfOne's picture
Submitted by OneOfOne on Mon, 07/06/2004 - 22:15.

hmm no, I only know one person that uses it and says its almost as good as reiserfs. but the closest filesystem in overall speed to reiser4 is reiserfs. but i guess i could give jfs a try sometime. thanks for pointing that out peace


YoussefAssad's picture
Submitted by YoussefAssad on Tue, 08/06/2004 - 08:21.

Really bizarre, these lockups and crashes you describe. Out of curiosity, how'd you suss out that they're FS-related?

-- Linux Egypt Lice Resident


OneOfOne's picture
Submitted by OneOfOne on Tue, 08/06/2004 - 23:38.

they are known bugs. the way reiser4 works, it depends too much on memory management and cpu scheduling. with 2.6.7-rc* there have been a lot of changes in both mm and cpu sched, Zam promised us to fix that asap but it's been hard since the lead dev left...

peace


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.